SIP trunking vs cloud phone system (UCaaS): which should you choose?

18/11/26 Wavenet
SIP trunking vs cloud phone system (UCaaS): which should you choose?

The UK's old analogue phone network is being retired. According to UK government, landlines and other devices that rely on the public switched telephone network (PSTN) need to be "fully upgraded by January 2027", and providers are advising business customers to move "at the earliest opportunity".

To find out how the deadline affects your business, read our guide on PSTN switch-off dates explained or use our step-by-step planning tool.

Moving off the old network means choosing a new way to make and receive calls. Two of the main options are SIP trunking or a cloud phone system, also known as unified communications as a service (UCaaS).

Both use the internet to carry calls, but they suit different business needs, budgets and plans. SIP trunking connects the phone system you already have to the internet, while a cloud phone system replaces it with a service hosted by your provider. This guide explains how they differ, when each makes sense and the questions to ask before you decide.

What is SIP trunking?

SIP trunking replaces traditional phone lines (analogue or ISDN) with a virtual connection over the internet. It plugs into your existing phone system, or PBX, so you keep your handsets and call features while your calls travel digitally.

SIP stands for Session Initiation Protocol, the standard used to set up voice calls over IP networks. A "trunk" is simply a bundle of lines, or channels, that your business shares.

Here's what SIP trunking gives you:

  • It's a true ISDN replacement, so you keep the phone system you've invested in (as long as it's SIP-compatible).
  • It scales easily. Add or remove channels as you need them.
  • It helps keep costs down. Internal calls are free, and multi-site businesses can run on fewer connections.
  • It supports resilience. Disaster recovery and geographic flexibility help keep calls flowing if a site goes down.
  • It works with Microsoft Teams. SIP trunking can connect Teams to the public phone network through Direct Routing.

The trade-off is that you still own and maintain a phone system. You're responsible for its hardware, software updates and eventual replacement.

What is a cloud phone system (UCaaS)?

A cloud phone system, or UCaaS, moves your whole phone system into the cloud. There's no PBX on site. Your provider hosts and manages everything, and you pay a monthly subscription per user.

UCaaS usually brings voice, video meetings, messaging and collaboration together in one app that works on desk phones, computers and mobiles. Typical features include:

  • Call forwarding, advanced call routing and call recording
  • Call queues, interactive voice response (IVR) menus and voicemail
  • Screen and file sharing
  • Apps for desktop and mobile, so people can take business calls anywhere

Because there's no on-site hardware, there's less to install, maintain and upgrade. Adding a new starter is a matter of adding a user.

The trade-off is that you rely on your provider's platform and features, and costs are ongoing rather than one-off. For a full introduction to cloud phone systems, read What is UCaaS? A simple guide for UK businesses.

SIP trunking vs UCaaS: side-by-side comparison

The biggest difference is where your phone system lives. With SIP trunking it stays on your premises, and with UCaaS it moves to the cloud.

Feature SIP trunking Cloud phone system (UCaaS)
What it replaces Your phone lines (analogue or ISDN) Your phone lines and your phone system
On-site equipment Keep your existing PBX and handsets Just handsets, apps or headsets, with the system hosted in the cloud
Cost model Lower monthly cost per channel, plus owning and maintaining your PBX Monthly subscription per user, with low upfront cost
Set-up Quick if your PBX is SIP-compatible Quick for new users, with number porting and handsets to plan
Features Whatever your PBX supports Calling, video, messaging, collaboration and emerging AI features in one app
Remote and hybrid working Depends on your PBX Built in, on any device
Scalability Add or remove channels Add or remove users
Maintenance and upgrades Your responsibility (or your maintainer's) Handled by the provider
Microsoft Teams calling Yes, through Direct Routing Some platforms integrate with Teams, and Operator Connect is another route
Best for Organisations with a recent PBX or specialist call handling Organisations ready to retire on-site kit or with ageing systems

When to choose SIP trunking

SIP trunking is a strong option if your existing phone system remains reliable and supported.

  • You've invested in a PBX recently and want to get full value from it.
  • You rely on specialist call handling, such as complex call routing, integrations or recording built into your current system.
  • You run high call volumes or many sites and want shared channels that scale.
  • You want a stepping stone. SIP trunking gets you off ISDN or analogue lines now, so you can move to the cloud later, on your own timescale.
  • You want Teams calling with your own carrier. SIP trunking plus Direct Routing connects Microsoft Teams to the phone network.

When to choose a cloud phone system (UCaaS)

UCaaS makes sense when you're ready to stop managing phone hardware.

  • Your PBX is ageing or out of support, and replacing it would be costly.
  • Your teams work in different places and need to take business calls on any device.
  • You want calling, meetings and messaging in one place, rather than separate tools.
  • You'd prefer predictable monthly costs to large one-off hardware spending.
  • You're growing or changing quickly and need to add users and sites easily.

What about Microsoft Teams?

If your organisation already uses Microsoft Teams, you can turn it into your phone system. There are two main ways to connect Teams to the public phone network:

Option How it works Good fit for
Direct Routing Connects Teams to the phone network using SIP trunks through a certified session border controller Organisations that want flexibility, existing SIP or PBX integration, or complex routing
Operator Connect Your operator connects calls straight into Teams, with set-up that can take minutes and the option to keep your existing numbers Organisations that want a simpler, fully managed set-up

The Liverpool Institute for the Performing Arts (LIPA) chose Direct Routing. We moved LIPA's phone lines off ISDN onto SIP trunking and connected them to Teams, so staff can make external calls from the Teams app they already use. LIPA also retired two on-site servers, which has reduced power use and hardware maintenance. Read the LIPA case study.

Questions to ask before you decide

Your answers to these questions will usually point you clearly towards one option.

Question If yes, consider Why
Is your PBX new and still supported? SIP trunking Get full value from your investment
Is your PBX out of support or due for replacement? UCaaS Avoid buying new on-site hardware
Do most staff work remotely or across sites? UCaaS Calls follow people on any device
Do you already use Microsoft Teams every day? Teams with Direct Routing or Operator Connect One app for calls, chat and meetings
Do you rely on complex call routing or integrations in your current system? SIP trunking (for now) Keep what works while you plan
Do you want predictable monthly costs? UCaaS Per-user subscription, low upfront cost
Do you want a cloud system dedicated to your organisation? Private cloud UC Geo-redundant hosting on a monthly pay-as-you-go model

Whichever you choose, check three things before you switch:

  1. Your connectivity. Both options carry calls over your internet connection, so it needs enough capacity and resilience. Busy sites may benefit from a dedicated leased line.
  2. Your numbers. Make sure you can keep your existing phone numbers when you move, and review whether your inbound numbers still suit how customers reach you.
  3. Everything else on your lines. Alarms, door entry, lifts and payment terminals can also rely on the old network. Our PSTN replacement services match each analogue service to a digital alternative.

Find the right phone system for your business

We offer SIP trunking, cloud phone systems and Teams calling, so we'll recommend the option that fits how your business works.

  • SIP trunking gives you a true ISDN replacement that keeps your current phone system.
  • UCaaS brings cloud calling, collaboration and call management together on a monthly subscription.
  • Direct Routing and Operator Connect turn Microsoft Teams into your phone system.
  • Phone systems cover handsets and infrastructure, for fixed-line or cloud.

The switch-off deadline is January 2027, so planning your move now gives you time to test the new system and switch at a pace that suits you.

Talk to us about the right option for your business or explore our unified communications solutions.

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between SIP trunking and UCaaS?

SIP trunking replaces your phone lines but keeps your existing on-site phone system (PBX). UCaaS replaces both the lines and the phone system with a cloud service you pay for per user.

Is SIP the same as VoIP?

They're closely related. VoIP (voice over internet protocol) is the general term for making calls over the internet. SIP is the protocol most VoIP services use to set up calls. SIP trunking is one type of VoIP service, and cloud phone systems are another.

Is SIP trunking being phased out?

SIP trunking is a digital service, so it carries on working after the PSTN switch-off. It's one of the main ways businesses replace ISDN and analogue lines.

Can I keep my phone numbers?

In most cases, yes. Both SIP trunking and cloud phone systems let you keep your existing numbers by porting them to the new service.

Can I use SIP trunking with Microsoft Teams?

Yes. Direct Routing uses SIP trunks to connect Microsoft Teams to the public phone network, so people can make and receive external calls in Teams.

Which is cheaper, SIP trunking or UCaaS?

It depends on your set-up. SIP trunking usually has lower monthly costs if you already own a working PBX. UCaaS avoids hardware costs and replaces them with a per-user subscription, which is often better value when your PBX needs replacing.

What internet connections do I need?

Both options need a reliable connection with enough bandwidth for your call volumes. A dedicated leased line, or a separate connection just for voice, helps protect call quality on busy sites.

Do I need to switch before January 2027?

Yes, if you still use analogue or ISDN lines. GOV.UK says landlines and other PSTN-reliant devices need to be fully upgraded by January 2027, and providers advise moving as early as possible.

Contact us to modernise your business communications