Backup or replication?

22/05/25 Wavenet
Backup or replication? placeholder thumbnail

When considering whether to backup or replicate to protect your data, there’s a lot to consider.

Your business creates and uses a lot of data. If you were to experience any form of disruption that impacts your data or access to it, you need to know where to focus your resources to enable you to resume operations as swiftly as possible. Your main options are backup or replication. So which do you choose, and why?

Paul Timson our Product Manager for business continuity, shares his top tips and advice on how to get this right…

Firstly, it’s important to classify your data, applications and their dependencies so that you can apply the most appropriate level of protection to all of your data. This will help you to focus on recovering what’s most important when recovery is required, so that you don’t prioritise less important data at the expense of something more critical.

Working out recovery time and recovery point objectives

Customer facing systems need to be recovered quickly if there’s an incident. It’s important to set a recovery time objective (RTO) that you can plan for, so that you have a strategy for recovering your data before productivity, customer service and even your reputation, are impacted by downtime. (Your RTO is your maximum acceptable period of downtime.) There will be data that’s not just important, it’s business-critical and the impact of its loss can be measured by the second – you not only need to think about availability and downtime, you also need to meet your required recovery point objective (RPO) so that you can make adequate provision to keep critical data loss to an absolute minimum. (Your RPO is your maximum acceptable amount of data loss, measured in time.) Once you consider your data loss tolerance, imagine a situation where your data gets stolen (exfiltrated) from your company and held to ransom.

Encrypting your commercially sensitive data or crown jewels, is essential to ensure that even if your data is stolen, it’s unreadable. Immutability is important because it makes your backup copies read-only and no-one can delete them. These are the basics you need to get right before you begin to look at the wider attack threats from cybercrime which we’ll look at another time.

Some initial data protection considerations

Before making any decisions about backup and replication, it’s important to remember that how you protect your data will impact your recovery options. Knowing what systems interact with other systems and even external supply chain systems will impact your recovery plans.

6 key data protection questions to help inform your strategy…

Important questions that you need to think about, across your data sets and workloads:

  • Do you know where your data is stored? Is it on your premises and encrypted or stored elsewhere like public cloud? Is it immutable and in another location when it’s backed up? You must ensure you have an encrypted, immutable air-gapped copy of your data as your reliable go to source for recovery.
  • Do you know if your data is all protected and how many different tools and teams you operate to keep it safe? In an ideal world one product to backup everything would be perfect, and it can be done. However, usually backup tools have grown organically to protect this or that, and there are different silos of data and teams to manage them, all with different capabilities. This can be a big overhead so it’s well worth looking at an overhaul of your backups to see if one tool can do all of it – it’s likely to pay for itself with saving in management overheads. The other big benefit of a single tool is that it can help you in managing your dependency mapping, so recovery from any incident becomes easier.
  • How often do you test that you can fully recover - and how long does it take, with how many people involved? On-demand and automated rehearsals are now becoming a standard requirement of data protection and recovery because an annual DR test no longer cuts the mustard. Regular weekly/monthly testing can prove your recovery plans and timescales whilst also flagging up any issues before you really need to rely on them. If you’re only testing once or twice a year, consider adopting an automated on-demand approach as these are often easy to do and don’t involve lots of resource from your company or provider and the benefits are huge. Not least of which is, if you perform an automated recovery on what you believe is a dependent group of servers or applications (a subset of your entire estate) and then find there’s a change that’s been made or a new application installed which means this now also needs to be included. Better to find out before you need to rely on it!
  • How much data can you tolerate losing? Zero data loss is the aim, but we all know reality just doesn’t match that unless you have very deep pockets and endless resources. Losing an hours’ worth of data or 15 minutes can be costly but this is where valuing your data and its dependencies is key. The value of the data will then help you protect it accordingly and give your business the ability to determine the loss vs cost decision-making. Focussing on what we call your ‘critical viable business’ - what’s the minimum IT setup that will keep you in business and what workloads, apps and networking will be needed to provide it? This is a great place to start and will help prioritise your recovery.
  • Do you know the relative importance and dependencies of your different types of data? Similar to other points we’ve discussed already, the value of data and its dependencies runs right through every aspect of data protection and recovery. Knowing how data moves between systems, understanding where it is at risk - does it pass over networks outside your organisation? Knowing your systems and the data they work on will drive your decisions on protection and will impact recovery. This feeds into your recovery strategy as often, inter-dependent systems need to be recovered together.
  • If one application is compromised and needs recovering, will other dependent systems also need to be rewound to the same point to maintain consistency? Today’s IT very rarely sits in isolation, particularly with the advent of containers where developers can build small interacting components into an application. Recovering only part of that group of interworking parts may result in others failing because they are less or more up to date than those recovered. This is most starkly demonstrated with point-of-sale applications where customers may interact with an application and choose a product to purchase, which then passes information to a stock system and then a billing system and finally logistics to get it delivered. If the stock system has an issue and is recovered to, say, last night, but the other systems are up to date as of now, the stock system may not report correct stock levels or refuse to work as it cannot work with the now out of sync billing system. So, it pays to know what each component talks to and relies on when recovering partial systems.

So what does this all mean? Should you backup or replicate or both?

I recommend that you always backup, this can be as frequent as every 15 minutes, if need be, and replicate only as required for selected key workloads.

Replication is brilliant for what we refer to as ‘traditional IT disasters’, such as user error, upgrades gone wrong, malicious insider, fire, server failure…the list is endless.

Replication is not so good when a cyber incident occurs and here’s my reasoning, whether you agree with me or not:

  • Backups can be achieved every 15 minutes compared to seconds for replication, which means that for replication to be better than frequent backup, your cyber incident needs to be cleaned up within 15 minutes, which is unlikely.
  • Replication is intended to be able to failover immediately an incident occurs. In a cyber incident you cannot failover because you will failover to a duplicate problem. You will have called in your cyber incident responders from Wavenet or another provider, who will spend hours and often days forensically investigating the infiltration, the damage and the steps to remediate so you don’t get a repeat break in.
  • Once you have passed the seconds/minutes elapsed time that replication gives you, recovering from a backup becomes more attractive. It is possible for replication tools to keep a journal for up to 30 days, so it may be possible after the cyber teams have finished and give you a safe restore window, replication can still be of use. However, booting directly from a clean backup offers the same options at a lower cost than recovery from replication. The dwell time that an infiltration has been in progress is on average longer than 30 days, rendering replication obsolete.
  • However your cyber incident management team supports you, there will be the need for a cleanroom or isolated recovery environment in which to restore your data to be checked as clean by forensics before you restore to the required recovery location, whether that be public cloud or our range of recovery options. Each workload and its dependencies and the recovery order and point in time need to be considered as we have mentioned in the earlier points.

Benefit from an experienced business continuity and cyber resilience provider

Both backup and replication have their place, but no incident is the same for any business so it’s important to seek advice from a provider with industry and recovery experience. Traditional data protection and recovery will protect you well when it is done correctly and looked after, but please do not rely on this when cyber comes calling – specialist responses are required here and it’s important to have the right protection in place.

Paul Timson Headshot

About the author

Paul Timson is the Product Manager in business continuity at Wavenet. He has worked in the business continuity field for almost his entire career, and with Wavenet for over 35 years. Starting out helping DEC VAX and AXP customers, through to delivering our comprehensive business continuity, disaster recovery and cyber resilience services as a technical engineer, to now planning and looking to the future to ensure we’re able to protect our customers, come what may.

Backup & Recovery, Cyber Security, business continuity

Latest blogs

See all posts
Placeholder thumbnail
Fusing networks and security to create tomorrow's digital infrastructure

Embrace a seamless digital transformation with SASE technology In the whirl of digital advancement, the lines between networking and security have blurred, paving the way for a new approach to connectivity and protection: Secure Access Service Edge or SASE. Imagine SASE as the ultimate multi-tasker - merging high-speed avenues like SD-WAN with the digital world's watchdogs - firewalls, Zero-Trust Network Access (ZTNA), and cloud security tools - all in one, cloud-delivered package. This powerhouse ensures that connectivity doesn't just mean getting online; it means doing so swiftly, securely, and smartly. Why we champion an integrated approach At our core, we champion simplicity and security. Connectivity and security shouldn't be complicated or separate. Our mission is to standardise and deliver cutting-edge SASE solutions that are easy to manage, highly secure, and adaptable - because in today's digital world, flexibility isn't just an advantage; it's a business imperative. What SASE means for your business Let's dive into what this really means for businesses moving through the clouds and beyond. With SASE, networking and security no longer run on different wavelengths. They're part of the same conversation, which means deploying and managing a network that's as secure as it is flexible. The benefits of SASE that you can expect: Lightning-fast, direct access to all the apps and data you need, with no lag. A single, cloud-native platform that manages all your monitoring and security needs - simplifying life for your IT team. Upgraded protection for your on-the-go staff, keeping them safe wherever work takes them. Unmatched control and insights into every SaaS application you use, whether it's on the radar or not. A network infrastructure that not only scales with your business but does so smoothly and efficiently. And for those pondering the complexities of integrating SASE into their existing network, we've got your back. As a seasoned Cisco Gold Partner, our team of Cisco-certified experts are ready to tailor a highly reliable, scalable, and ironclad SASE strategy for you. With over two decades of experience to draw on, we're not just offering a service; we're driving transformation. Our proven Cisco-centric SASE solutions As a Cisco Gold Partner, we leverage over twenty years of expertise to tailor a dependable, scalable, and robust SASE strategy for your organisation: Cisco Umbrella SIG with Secure Connect: Offering unparalleled, location-agnostic connectivity that seamlessly links your team and technology, while simultaneously bolstering your defence against security threats through a unified approach. Providing your business with leading cloud security that proactively safeguards your digital landscape, ensuring tailored, comprehensive protection for your vital assets. Built with Cisco Secure Access and Umbrella SIG. Cisco Meraki SD-WAN: Modernise your network with an optimised WAN that guarantees strong performance and reliable connectivity for every user and device across your organisation. Cisco Thousand Eyes: Harness unmatched visibility and performance insights across your network, cloud, and SaaS ecosystems, empowering your enterprise to optimise digital experiences decisively. Ready to rethink your digital infrastructure? If you're keen on a future where connectivity and security walk hand in hand, let's get the conversation started. With us, you're not just adopting SASE; you're embracing a secure, integrated, and incredibly agile digital infrastructure. Picture setting up your new digital base with us as piecing together your favourite puzzle; you don't need all the pieces initially. We build your dream setup step by step, ensuring each piece fits perfectly over time to create a seamless, unified solution tailored for your business needs. Welcome to the forefront of networking and security. Welcome to your new digital baseline.

Read more
Placeholder thumbnail
How can businesses dispose of devices in an environmentally friendly way?

What is WEEE compliance? Electronic waste (e-waste) is one of the fastest growing waste streams today, with the UK generating 1.7 million tonnes* per year. As our reliance on electronic devices such as laptops, desktops, mobiles, and office equipment increases, so does the importance of responsible IT equipment disposal in the UK. When devices become faulty or outdated, the vast majority are simply disposed of, adding to the mounting electronic waste (e-waste) in landfills. This creates even more WEEE (Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment). Effective responsible IT asset disposal in the UK is crucial to reduce environmental impact and support a sustainable future. With rapid technological advancements, upgrading IT infrastructure, and increasing regulations on WEEE compliance, adopting eco-friendly electronics recycling solutions is more important than ever. If we don’t all start to reduce, reuse, and recycle electronic devices, this is only set to get worse. We all have a role in minimising e-waste in the workplace, supporting the planet, and reducing demand for resource-intensive manufacturing What do companies do with old electronic devices? According to Sue Owens, Head of Supply Chain Services at Wavenet: “There isn’t a single answer to the climate crisis, or how we can recycle our way out of trouble, but responsible electronic device recycling and secure data destruction are essential parts of the solution. We need to look at all methods of recycling. Even the smallest contribution in reducing e-waste in the workplace adds up to be part of the bigger picture.” Recycling old laptops, mobiles, and other IT hardware not only helps manage the rising tide of end-of-life equipment recycling but also ensures compliance with WEEE directives. Proper certified electronic waste disposal providers help companies turn obsolete devices into environmentally safe recyclables or components, reducing the need for raw material extraction. Sue continues: ”The more organisations recycle, the less we need to mine. While the mining industry is a major contributor to planet-warming emissions, it also holds the key to a net-zero future. We don’t need to extract more – we need less. As clean energy and EVs expand, the total amount of materials mined will actually decrease, and we can significantly reduce reliance on coal that still fuels the industry’s revenues. Less mining, more sustainability – that’s the future we must build. To make a difference, it’s up to organisations to recycle whatever we can; however, data destruction is critical to the security of your business. Compliance with the WEEE directive and recycling units back into the market, either as components, or broken down into their elements is a huge contributor.” How do businesses recycle computers and phones?

Read more
A happy house tenant is using an app on her phone to report a home issue to her housing provider
From risk to resolution: how Active Assessor helps you stay ahead of Awaab's Law

What does Awaab's Law mean and why does it matter? Damp and mould aren’t just inconvenient maintenance problems - they’re serious risks to tenant health, regulatory compliance, and the reputation of housing providers. Nearly 1 in 7 social homes in England failed to meet the Decent Homes Standard in 2023¹. On top of that, the NHS is estimated to spend £1.4 billion a year treating health issues related to cold, damp housing². And yet, more than half of tenants experiencing condensation, damp or mould don’t report it. Often, they don’t recognise the early signs, or they simply don’t believe they’ll be taken seriously. This silence leaves landlords in the dark and turns small, fixable issues into expensive, high-risk problems. From October, social landlords will be legally required to fix emergency hazards within 24 hours and investigate and repair dangerous damp and mould within set timeframes, under new legislation known as Awaab’s Law. Introduced in memory of two-year-old Awaab Ishak, who tragically died in 2020 after prolonged exposure to mould in his social housing, the law represents a major step toward improving housing safety and quality. It allows tenants to take legal action if landlords fail to comply and will be rolled out in phases, beginning with damp and mould, to ensure effective implementation. This approach aims to deliver meaningful, lasting change while honouring the efforts of Awaab’s family to secure justice. Awaab’s Law also supports the government’s broader plan for change, which includes a commitment to building 1.5 million new homes and delivering the biggest improvement to social and affordable housing in a generation. The challenge: strained teams & outdated systems Most housing providers care deeply about tenant safety. The problem isn’t willingness—it’s capacity. Maintenance teams, IT departments, and customer contact centres are already stretched thin. Spotting early-stage issues requires tools they simply don’t have. Traditional, manual inspections are expensive and slow. Reactive workflows leave little room to get ahead of problems. And despite growing demand for proactive service, only 13% of customers actually receive it. The systems many teams rely on today are fragmented, outdated, and not fit for the pressures of a post-Awaab world. The solution: Active Assessor by 8x8

Read more
Placeholder thumbnail
There's more to the PSTN switch-off than meets the eye

What is the PSTN switch-off? The impending PSTN (Public Switched Telephone Network) switch-off isn’t just about replacing traditional lines. It’s a seismic shift that impacts far more than most realise – and if you’re not prepared, it could cost your business dearly. Most companies are aware that traditional analogue lines and ISDN systems for calls and broadband are being phased out by January 2027. But what many don’t see is the vast ripple effect of this transition – touching everything from lifts to life-critical systems, cash machines, and even traffic lights. What does the PSTN switch-off mean in simple terms? When it comes to the PSTN switch-off, it’s easy to think that it is just about phone lines. But the truth is, it’s much more complex. Here is what’s at stake: Life-saving systems: fire alarms, major medical and safety devices, emergency alarms in care homes, emergency pendants, telemetry services monitoring boiler rooms, dams, sluice gates, and substations. Public infrastructure: traffic lights, bus stops, speed cameras, and traffic management systems. Business-critical devices: PDQ and payment terminals, ATMS, CCTV, video surveillance, door entry, security systems, and remote access points. Transport & emergency services: roadside AA/RAC recovery alerts and devices, and emergency phone lines in hazardous environments. Telecommunications & internet: leased lines, private networking facilities, dial-up lines, broadband DSL services, and international leased lines. Community & public services: emergency teams and vehicles, payphones, modems, industrial control, public alerts, and more. If every one of these vital systems suddenly loses connectivity – chaos, downtime, and danger could follow. The possible business impact of the PSTN switch-off could be financial losses, public safety risks and erosion of customer trust. The PSTN switch-off is a vital business resilience issue – the time to act is now Unlike many providers who may focus on the obvious, we see what others miss. Our team dives beneath the surface, examining your entire network ecosystem to identify what’s at risk when the PSTN switches off. We have mapped out the hidden web of critical systems that rely on legacy infrastructure – and yes, we’ve prepared solutions for each one. Check out our iceberg infographic to see a quick glance of the PSTN switch-off picture. The switch-off is just the tip of the iceberg. Without planning, your operations could face catastrophic disruption. Don’t let your business be caught unaware. Reach out today for an in-depth assessment, and explore solutions tailored to your critical systems. Because when it comes to the PSTN switch-off, we see beyond the iceberg – and help your business stay afloat.

Read more

Stay service-savvy

Get all the latest news and insights straight to your inbox.