Think your business is secure? Why assumed breach testing is the real test

23/05/25 Chris Watt
Think your business is secure? Why assumed breach testing is the real test placeholder thumbnail

It’s widely recognised that organisations worldwide face relentless external cyber threats from a variety of threat actors, but far less consideration is given to threats that may be coming from inside an organisation itself.

Insider threats can originate from a variety of sources, including malicious or disgruntled employees, or even external attackers who have compromised internal users through phishing or exploiting internal vulnerabilities. Furthermore, and more significantly, depending on the specific nature of the attack or breach, some threat actors can maintain prolonged access to any compromised internal systems, giving them endless opportunities to explore the internal networks and any valuable assets.

Why an assumed breach or rogue user exercise is essential

This is where advanced internal security testing such as an assumed breach, or rogue user exercise would come into play, unlike other forms of internal penetration test, including:

  • where the assessment could either be performed from a fully unauthenticated perspective, simulating an attacker who had managed to simply connect into the network and “see what they could see”, investigating and attacking as much as possible in the time available.
  • scanning the organisation’s networks and assets for patching and misconfigurations from an administrative perspective.

An assumed breach or rogue user assessment focuses on what an internal rogue user with standard domain user privileges could do within the network, rather than patching levels or other similar misconfigurations on various devices.

Such an assessment should consider multiple possible scenarios, as described above, particularly in terms of initial access, but the overall final objective is generally the same: Can such a rogue internal user, such as a disgruntled employee, or other threat actor who has managed to compromise the network through other means and can maintain their access, elevate their privileges, access sensitive data, or otherwise compromise the network further in some meaningful way?

 

How is an assumed breach assessment different from an unauthenticated internal penetration test?

While an assumed breach assessment can sometimes be considered an extension of a completely unauthenticated Internal penetration test (where an attacker simply plugs in an unknown laptop, or other remote device and begins exploring with no credentials), the boundary between these usually lies in whether an attacker can gain any form of authenticated foothold into the network, from an initial unauthenticated perspective. Since this is often a time-consuming practice, an assumed breach exercise can be regarded as a cost-effective middle ground, especially when budgets are tighter but organisations want to evaluate real internal risks.

What’s the difference between Red Team vs. assumed breach?

Some may ask how and where this differs from a Red Team engagement. The answer to this lies in the scope (breadth) and noise generated from such a test:

  • Red Teams generally assess a broader area of potential entry points, combining multiple forms or otherwise different tests into one engagement (OSINT, Social-Engineering, External Infrastructure, Web App, VPN etc), but also generally aim to be “quieter”, flying under the radar to avoid detection for as long as possible. However, this attempted detection avoidance normally means that things can take longer, hence Red Team engagements generally being spread over a longer period.
  • Assumed breach/ rogue user assessments on the other hand are still conducted within a much smaller commercial time window and need to be “louder” to still ensure good coverage.

What’s tested on an assumed breach assessment?

The type of testing you can do with a standard domain or low-privileged user account depends on how you want to simulate the attack, and ultimately whether there are any particular objectives to be attained. If the test is run from an organisation-owned device, such as a corporate laptop connected to the VPN, security policies might limit what the attacker can do. But if the test is done from an attacker-owned device with full admin rights, connected via VPN, this provides a broader and more accurate assessment - especially if this approach can be consistently repeated.

Assessments typically examine:

  • Number of users present on the domain
  • Domain’s password policy
  • The presence of any accounts whose sensitive password data may be retrievable by other domain users, via the design of Active Directory
  • Whether any such accounts are highly privileged, and/or whose plaintext passwords are retrievable (crackable) within a reasonable time
  • Quantity and identities of domain admin accounts
  • Examination of any networks shares available, and whether any sensitive data is contained within

Real-world lessons from insider-related attacks

Many organisations have experienced domain compromises due to misconfigurations or not following best practice - allowing even standard domain users to escalate privileges and take control of entire networks. These vulnerabilities are prevalent both on-premises and via virtual machines and networks in the cloud, emphasising that internal security is as vital as external defences.

Ready to strengthen your internal security?

An assumed breach or rogue user assessment provides invaluable insight into how well your defences hold up against internal threats. By simulating real-world scenarios, we identify weaknesses before malicious insiders or compromised accounts do.

If you would like to learn more about how we identify vulnerabilities with our range of services, including penetration testing, get in touch.

Chris Watt Picture

About the author

Chris Watt has been in the penetration testing arena for over 12 years, specialising in web application and API security. For the last few years he has been steadily branching out into other types of security, including advanced infrastructure and mobile app testing.

Cyber Security, Red Team, Assumed Breach

Latest blogs

See all posts
Placeholder thumbnail
Fusing networks and security to create tomorrow's digital infrastructure

Embrace a seamless digital transformation with SASE technology In the whirl of digital advancement, the lines between networking and security have blurred, paving the way for a new approach to connectivity and protection: Secure Access Service Edge or SASE. Imagine SASE as the ultimate multi-tasker - merging high-speed avenues like SD-WAN with the digital world's watchdogs - firewalls, Zero-Trust Network Access (ZTNA), and cloud security tools - all in one, cloud-delivered package. This powerhouse ensures that connectivity doesn't just mean getting online; it means doing so swiftly, securely, and smartly. Why we champion an integrated approach At our core, we champion simplicity and security. Connectivity and security shouldn't be complicated or separate. Our mission is to standardise and deliver cutting-edge SASE solutions that are easy to manage, highly secure, and adaptable - because in today's digital world, flexibility isn't just an advantage; it's a business imperative. What SASE means for your business Let's dive into what this really means for businesses moving through the clouds and beyond. With SASE, networking and security no longer run on different wavelengths. They're part of the same conversation, which means deploying and managing a network that's as secure as it is flexible. The benefits of SASE that you can expect: Lightning-fast, direct access to all the apps and data you need, with no lag. A single, cloud-native platform that manages all your monitoring and security needs - simplifying life for your IT team. Upgraded protection for your on-the-go staff, keeping them safe wherever work takes them. Unmatched control and insights into every SaaS application you use, whether it's on the radar or not. A network infrastructure that not only scales with your business but does so smoothly and efficiently. And for those pondering the complexities of integrating SASE into their existing network, we've got your back. As a seasoned Cisco Gold Partner, our team of Cisco-certified experts are ready to tailor a highly reliable, scalable, and ironclad SASE strategy for you. With over two decades of experience to draw on, we're not just offering a service; we're driving transformation. Our proven Cisco-centric SASE solutions As a Cisco Gold Partner, we leverage over twenty years of expertise to tailor a dependable, scalable, and robust SASE strategy for your organisation: Cisco Umbrella SIG with Secure Connect: Offering unparalleled, location-agnostic connectivity that seamlessly links your team and technology, while simultaneously bolstering your defence against security threats through a unified approach. Providing your business with leading cloud security that proactively safeguards your digital landscape, ensuring tailored, comprehensive protection for your vital assets. Built with Cisco Secure Access and Umbrella SIG. Cisco Meraki SD-WAN: Modernise your network with an optimised WAN that guarantees strong performance and reliable connectivity for every user and device across your organisation. Cisco Thousand Eyes: Harness unmatched visibility and performance insights across your network, cloud, and SaaS ecosystems, empowering your enterprise to optimise digital experiences decisively. Ready to rethink your digital infrastructure? If you're keen on a future where connectivity and security walk hand in hand, let's get the conversation started. With us, you're not just adopting SASE; you're embracing a secure, integrated, and incredibly agile digital infrastructure. Picture setting up your new digital base with us as piecing together your favourite puzzle; you don't need all the pieces initially. We build your dream setup step by step, ensuring each piece fits perfectly over time to create a seamless, unified solution tailored for your business needs. Welcome to the forefront of networking and security. Welcome to your new digital baseline.

Read more
Placeholder thumbnail
How can businesses dispose of devices in an environmentally friendly way?

What is WEEE compliance? Electronic waste (e-waste) is one of the fastest growing waste streams today, with the UK generating 1.7 million tonnes* per year. As our reliance on electronic devices such as laptops, desktops, mobiles, and office equipment increases, so does the importance of responsible IT equipment disposal in the UK. When devices become faulty or outdated, the vast majority are simply disposed of, adding to the mounting electronic waste (e-waste) in landfills. This creates even more WEEE (Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment). Effective responsible IT asset disposal in the UK is crucial to reduce environmental impact and support a sustainable future. With rapid technological advancements, upgrading IT infrastructure, and increasing regulations on WEEE compliance, adopting eco-friendly electronics recycling solutions is more important than ever. If we don’t all start to reduce, reuse, and recycle electronic devices, this is only set to get worse. We all have a role in minimising e-waste in the workplace, supporting the planet, and reducing demand for resource-intensive manufacturing What do companies do with old electronic devices? According to Sue Owens, Head of Supply Chain Services at Wavenet: “There isn’t a single answer to the climate crisis, or how we can recycle our way out of trouble, but responsible electronic device recycling and secure data destruction are essential parts of the solution. We need to look at all methods of recycling. Even the smallest contribution in reducing e-waste in the workplace adds up to be part of the bigger picture.” Recycling old laptops, mobiles, and other IT hardware not only helps manage the rising tide of end-of-life equipment recycling but also ensures compliance with WEEE directives. Proper certified electronic waste disposal providers help companies turn obsolete devices into environmentally safe recyclables or components, reducing the need for raw material extraction. Sue continues: ”The more organisations recycle, the less we need to mine. While the mining industry is a major contributor to planet-warming emissions, it also holds the key to a net-zero future. We don’t need to extract more – we need less. As clean energy and EVs expand, the total amount of materials mined will actually decrease, and we can significantly reduce reliance on coal that still fuels the industry’s revenues. Less mining, more sustainability – that’s the future we must build. To make a difference, it’s up to organisations to recycle whatever we can; however, data destruction is critical to the security of your business. Compliance with the WEEE directive and recycling units back into the market, either as components, or broken down into their elements is a huge contributor.” How do businesses recycle computers and phones?

Read more
A happy house tenant is using an app on her phone to report a home issue to her housing provider
From risk to resolution: how Active Assessor helps you stay ahead of Awaab's Law

What does Awaab's Law mean and why does it matter? Damp and mould aren’t just inconvenient maintenance problems - they’re serious risks to tenant health, regulatory compliance, and the reputation of housing providers. Nearly 1 in 7 social homes in England failed to meet the Decent Homes Standard in 2023¹. On top of that, the NHS is estimated to spend £1.4 billion a year treating health issues related to cold, damp housing². And yet, more than half of tenants experiencing condensation, damp or mould don’t report it. Often, they don’t recognise the early signs, or they simply don’t believe they’ll be taken seriously. This silence leaves landlords in the dark and turns small, fixable issues into expensive, high-risk problems. From October, social landlords will be legally required to fix emergency hazards within 24 hours and investigate and repair dangerous damp and mould within set timeframes, under new legislation known as Awaab’s Law. Introduced in memory of two-year-old Awaab Ishak, who tragically died in 2020 after prolonged exposure to mould in his social housing, the law represents a major step toward improving housing safety and quality. It allows tenants to take legal action if landlords fail to comply and will be rolled out in phases, beginning with damp and mould, to ensure effective implementation. This approach aims to deliver meaningful, lasting change while honouring the efforts of Awaab’s family to secure justice. Awaab’s Law also supports the government’s broader plan for change, which includes a commitment to building 1.5 million new homes and delivering the biggest improvement to social and affordable housing in a generation. The challenge: strained teams & outdated systems Most housing providers care deeply about tenant safety. The problem isn’t willingness—it’s capacity. Maintenance teams, IT departments, and customer contact centres are already stretched thin. Spotting early-stage issues requires tools they simply don’t have. Traditional, manual inspections are expensive and slow. Reactive workflows leave little room to get ahead of problems. And despite growing demand for proactive service, only 13% of customers actually receive it. The systems many teams rely on today are fragmented, outdated, and not fit for the pressures of a post-Awaab world. The solution: Active Assessor by 8x8

Read more
Placeholder thumbnail
There's more to the PSTN switch-off than meets the eye

What is the PSTN switch-off? The impending PSTN (Public Switched Telephone Network) switch-off isn’t just about replacing traditional lines. It’s a seismic shift that impacts far more than most realise – and if you’re not prepared, it could cost your business dearly. Most companies are aware that traditional analogue lines and ISDN systems for calls and broadband are being phased out by January 2027. But what many don’t see is the vast ripple effect of this transition – touching everything from lifts to life-critical systems, cash machines, and even traffic lights. What does the PSTN switch-off mean in simple terms? When it comes to the PSTN switch-off, it’s easy to think that it is just about phone lines. But the truth is, it’s much more complex. Here is what’s at stake: Life-saving systems: fire alarms, major medical and safety devices, emergency alarms in care homes, emergency pendants, telemetry services monitoring boiler rooms, dams, sluice gates, and substations. Public infrastructure: traffic lights, bus stops, speed cameras, and traffic management systems. Business-critical devices: PDQ and payment terminals, ATMS, CCTV, video surveillance, door entry, security systems, and remote access points. Transport & emergency services: roadside AA/RAC recovery alerts and devices, and emergency phone lines in hazardous environments. Telecommunications & internet: leased lines, private networking facilities, dial-up lines, broadband DSL services, and international leased lines. Community & public services: emergency teams and vehicles, payphones, modems, industrial control, public alerts, and more. If every one of these vital systems suddenly loses connectivity – chaos, downtime, and danger could follow. The possible business impact of the PSTN switch-off could be financial losses, public safety risks and erosion of customer trust. The PSTN switch-off is a vital business resilience issue – the time to act is now Unlike many providers who may focus on the obvious, we see what others miss. Our team dives beneath the surface, examining your entire network ecosystem to identify what’s at risk when the PSTN switches off. We have mapped out the hidden web of critical systems that rely on legacy infrastructure – and yes, we’ve prepared solutions for each one. Check out our iceberg infographic to see a quick glance of the PSTN switch-off picture. The switch-off is just the tip of the iceberg. Without planning, your operations could face catastrophic disruption. Don’t let your business be caught unaware. Reach out today for an in-depth assessment, and explore solutions tailored to your critical systems. Because when it comes to the PSTN switch-off, we see beyond the iceberg – and help your business stay afloat.

Read more

Stay service-savvy

Get all the latest news and insights straight to your inbox.